“God’s Organization”
Or how to win cases before the world and lose them before God
“However, when they hand you over, do not become anxious about how or what you are to speak, for what you are to speak will be given you in that hour; for the ones speaking are not just you, but it is the spirit of your Father that speaks by you.” – Matthew 10:19-20, New World Translation (2013)
Imagine a shopkeeper who, on the same day, says two opposite things.
In the morning, to a new customer who wandered in by chance: “Our firm was founded in 1919. Before us, the market was nothing but charlatans.”
In the afternoon, to a customer who has been coming back for months and ventures a doubt — couldn’t I shop somewhere else? —: “Good heavens, no. Our firm has always existed. Always. There has never been anyone else.”
Founded in 1919, and in existence for ever. The same shopkeeper, the same counter, the same day.
It isn’t a shopkeeper. It’s an argument. And plenty of people use it.
It is worth saying straight away, because it decides how everything else should be read. What follows takes one single case and follows it closely: one organization, its books, its dates, its lawsuits. But the case is a sample, not a target. The mechanism is not theirs alone: it belongs to anyone who proclaims himself God’s visible channel on earth and then, with that claim on his shoulders, has to survive inside the world.
And if the subject were money, we would not even be looking in the right direction. Their Adventist cousins — born of the same disappointment of 1844, the same mistaken arithmetic about the end of the world — have had an agreement with the Italian State since 1986, and for decades have been collecting the otto per mille (the “eight per thousand” share of income tax that Italian taxpayers can assign to a recognized religious body) which Jehovah’s Witnesses have been denied. Same root, another branch, tap wide open. Richer and better-connected organizations are not hard to find.
Which makes the question more interesting, not less. Because if the problem were the greed of one group, it would be enough to change groups.
“God has always had an organization on earth.”
It is one of those sentences repeated so often that people stop hearing it. A mantra. And mantras have one flaw: they work as long as nobody takes them seriously.
Let us try taking it seriously. Just for one afternoon.
And let us take it seriously where it is born, because that sentence has a precise place and moment.
It does not come out at the beginning. At the beginning the talk is of other things: paradise, the dead who sleep, God’s name. It comes out later, at the Bible study, when the student has already nodded along to many things and one day, timidly, asks: but couldn’t I, in my own way?
That is when the card is played. “You see, you can’t go your own way: God has always had an organization on earth.”
A pity that, a few years earlier, that same student had heard another date. A far more precise one.
Because the 1919 sentence and the “always” sentence do not live on the same page. They live in two different rooms, and do two different jobs. The 1919 serves to say who they are: the restoration, the only ones, the sole survivors after eighteen centuries of darkness.
The “always” serves to say what you cannot do: go off on your own. One sentence boasts, the other fences in.
Nor is it a coincidence where the “always” sentence was written. Not in a leaflet left on the doorstep — there the “1919” is more than enough to say in one line who they are. It is found in chapter twenty-three of a book that presented itself as the study manual: the book said so itself, describing the study held in private homes, where “a Bible study aid, such as this book you are reading,” is used as the basis for the discussion.
Chapter twenty-three: one of the last. It reached, that is, those who had already gone through twenty-two chapters, who had kept going for months, both in the study and at their meetings, and were beginning — precisely then — to ask the awkward question.
And look at how that chapter ended. With an invitation to leave and to enter: to leave one’s own religion, notify it of one’s withdrawal, sign the removal papers. It was the threshold chapter. And the phrase that serves to stop you ever turning back — “God has always had an organization” — stood, as luck would have it, right there, on the threshold.
A note. That book is no longer studied today — it still spoke of the “generation of 1914”, a doctrine they later had to adjust. Others have come since, and others will come. But the book is not the point. The point is that the concept — “God has always had an organization” — has passed unscathed from one manual to the next, smoothly, never corrected. The volumes change; the slogan stays. In fact, whatever survives every revision is exactly what deserves a closer look.
But let us return to the point, because that is where everything is decided.
“Always” leaves no gaps. It means in the fourth century too. In 1100 too. In 1400, in 1600. It means that in every age, from the death of the apostles to today, that visible, recognizable organization, the custodian of truth, would have existed on earth. It is an enormous claim. And it is, at least in theory, verifiable: if something has always existed, it should leave a trace in every century. A name. A place. Someone.
So let us do the simplest and fairest thing there is. Let us ask them to fill that “always”. Not with our sources: with theirs. Let us ask them to show us God’s organization on earth in 1400.
And let us open the very book in which they tell their own history.
It is a volume devoted precisely to this: reconstructing the thread of God’s people from the first Christians to today. A whole chapter covers the middle centuries, the dark ones, from the death of the last apostle to the nineteenth century. And it is a crowded chapter: Ignatius of Antioch, Cyprian of Carthage, Augustine, the emperor Constantine all pass through it. And further on Luther, Zwingli, Calvin. And then Miller, and even Marx and Darwin.
Dozens of names. A panorama of fifteen centuries.
And now let us stop and ask the only question that matters: in all this crowd of names, where are God’s people?
They are not there.
Reread the chapter line by line. The names it gives are all — all — of apostates, pagan philosophers, bishops building the hierarchy, reformers whom the book itself judges inadequate. Not one faithful believer. Not one group. Not a single link in the chain that should run “always”, unbroken, century after century. The book that tells the history of God’s people cannot name, for fifteen centuries, God’s people.
And careful, because here we must be precise, or they will answer us in ten seconds. The book nowhere writes “in those centuries there was not a single faithful believer” (and they cannot say it, because in their own doctrine the 144,000 are spread across 2,000 years of history). It does not say so. It simply, in the telling, finds no one to name. It is a silence, not a statement. But it is a silence that weighs like a confession: when you have to trace the line of faithfulness through the centuries and cannot write a single name along that line, there is no line.
And the big names? The ones a hasty reader would expect to find — Luther, Calvin, the reformers who at least did something against Rome? The book examines them, and discards them. In its own words, the Reformation “did not, however, mark a return to true worship and doctrine.” They kept the Trinity, the immortality of the soul, the division between clergy and laity; they continued, it says, to be part of the world. Rejected. So don’t even try to bring them in as links in the chain: it was they who removed them, not us.
So where does the history of the ever-existing organization end up, in that book? Look at the table of contents: everything can be read there. One chapter: “Christian Witnesses of Jehovah in the First Century”. The next: “The Great Apostasy Develops”. And the one after that jumps straight to the nineteenth century, to “Proclaiming the Lord’s Return” and to a small group of Bible students — them.
From the first century to the nineteenth. In between, a single chapter, and it is called apostasy.
Eighteen centuries. The “always” of the first sentence was supposed to fill them all. Their own history book crosses them without finding anyone inside.
At this point let us put the two sentences we started from back on the table. Side by side, bare.
The first: “Jehovah has always guided his servants in an organized way.” In an organized way: that is, with an organization. Always: that is, in every age, without interruption.
The second, from their own literature: that organization — the channel that guides, administers, dispenses spiritual food — was appointed in 1919.
There is no way to keep both. Either “always”, or “since 1919”. Of the two, at least one is false. And it was not we who chose them: they wrote them, on two pages from the same house.
Now you understand why two rooms were needed. “Always” is the sentence for the student who resists: you can’t go your own way, you were never an exception, God has always worked like this.
“Since 1919” is the sentence for the first contact: everything else was darkness, we are the light come back. One fences in, the other crowns. And each refutes the other, because they cannot stand up together.
One last foothold remains, and it is fair to grant it before they use it. They might say: “But we didn’t mean an uninterrupted organization. We meant that, in the dark centuries, there were still individual faithful ones scattered here and there.” Very well. But then the organized “always” falls, because scattered individuals are not an organization — they are the exact opposite of a single, visible, recognizable channel. And if scattered faithful individuals, each on his own, were really enough to keep the flame alive for eighteen centuries, then the question with which everything began falls too: why couldn’t I, in my own way?
They could. For eighteen centuries, by their own history, there was nothing else.
Shepherds and teachers, or lawyers and accountants?
Before going further, though, the most important concession of all has to be made — and we had better make it ourselves, because it is exactly the one they are waiting for. In the New Testament there are assignments, and Paul lists them: “And he gave some, apostles; and some, prophets; and some, evangelists; and some, pastors and teachers” (Ephesians 4:11). Assigned roles, not spontaneity. And it is one of the verses they quote most often, for a simple reason: it really does say this. Their own translation says it too, rendering it the same way — “some as evangelizers, some as shepherds and teachers”. On this there is nothing to object.
But the sentence does not end there, and the tail is decisive. Those assignments, Paul writes, are given “for the perfecting of the saints, for the work of the ministry, for the edifying of the body of Christ” (Ephesians 4:12). So there is a declared purpose, and it is entirely internal: helping people grow. Not administering assets, not obtaining recognition, not defending a position before the world.
So the question is not whether God ever assigned roles, nor whether his people were ever organized. He did assign them, and from Moses onwards that people was extremely well organized: censuses, a camp laid out by tribes, a priesthood, shifts of service. On this there is no contest, and we are not looking for one. What we dispute is two things, and it is best to state them separately. The first: that those assignments translate into the organization in the sense they give it today — a legal entity with headquarters, committees, legal departments, balance sheets and assets to defend. The second: that such a thing has existed always, on earth, without interruption. And the second, we have just watched short-circuit all by itself.
On the first, try an experiment. Reread Paul’s list as today’s apparatus would rewrite it, according to the skills it really needs: “And he gave some as lawyers, some as judges, some as accountants and auditors.” Does it ring true? It jars.
And that is exactly the point: that is the list of trades that keep a structure like that standing, and not quite the list Paul had in mind. A shepherd and a legal department are not exactly the same thing, and no translation will turn them into one.
Legally establishing the work?
This is not a question to be settled on paper. Because an organization is not judged by how it describes itself, but by how it behaves. So far we have looked at what it says it is: let us set the words aside and look at the actions. Let us see how this “organization of God” is run when the difficult moment arrives.
And the difficult moment, for anyone who declares himself a “sheep in the midst of wolves”, has a precise form: the courtroom.
On this there is a verse everyone quotes from memory: Paul, before Festus, crying “I appeal to Caesar!” (Acts 25:11). There you are, they say: even the apostle used the empire’s court. He too protected himself legally. So it is lawful, indeed a duty, to “legally establish” the work (Philippians 1:7).
Good. Let us take the verse seriously, as we did with the slogan. And let us read it to the end, not just up to the convenient comma.
Because Paul’s appeal has an outcome, and it is written shortly afterwards. King Agrippa pronounces it, and nobody ever quotes it: “This man might have been set at liberty, if he had not appealed unto Caesar” (Acts 26:32). Let us stop on this line. The appeal to Caesar did not save Paul. It chained him. It shipped him to Rome, towards trial and, in the end, towards death. It was not a shield to get him off: it was a one-way ticket to the highest witness stand in the empire, exactly where Paul wanted to arrive in order to testify.
Do you feel the difference? Paul does not appeal to Caesar to preserve himself. He appeals to expose himself further and carry the witness further. He uses the world’s court to walk towards the wolves, not to build himself an armoured enclosure and hire guard dogs. Reading that episode as “get yourselves a good lawyer” means turning what happened upside down: the victim becomes the plaintiff, the man going towards death becomes the man getting himself to safety.
And it is not an isolated case. Every time the first Christians ended up before a court, they did one thing only: they bore witness. They never asked for legal recognition, a stamp, a protection. Their hearers were to accept the truth in their hearts: it was not a battle to change their laws (Acts 26:27-29). It is exactly what Jesus had foretold: you will be dragged before governors and kings (Matthew 10:18; Mark 13:9). Dragged. Not “you will drag”. Not “you will sue”. The verb is that of the prey hauled off by force, never that of the plaintiff bringing a case.
Then there is a verse which, on its own, is worth a whole talk. Paul rebukes the Christians who took their disputes to the courts, and asks: why do you “go to law before the unjust, and not before the saints?” (1 Corinthians 6:1). It is Paul himself who calls that forum unjust. And here is the short circuit: if you yourself recognize a court as unjust, how can you then run to it asking for recognition of your work? The unjust are not the judge from whom one requests a certificate of legitimacy.
There remains the best card they can play, and it rests on a single word. Paul, in Philippians, speaks of the “defence and confirmation” of the gospel, and in their translation that passage becomes “defending and legally establishing the good news” (Philippians 1:7). Legally: that is, in the courts, with the laws of men. On this they have built an entire doctrine of legal protection.
And let us say it ourselves, before they do: a legal nuance in that Greek word really does exist. The papyri use it for the guarantee that accompanies a sale. We did not invent it, and neither did they.
Only, in the papyri that guarantee is given by the seller. He is the one who puts himself on the line to guarantee. Asking to be recognized is the opposite gesture: it is presenting oneself before a third party so that he will guarantee.
But the real point is not the adverb. It is the verb. Establishing — legally. And nobody establishes anything legally on his own: legal standing is conferred. Someone has to confer it.
Conferred by whom, according to their translation?
Not by those who hear the preaching: from them you obtain no legal standing. You obtain it from an office. From a court. From the very people whom, in another of his letters, Paul calls unjust (1 Corinthians 6:1).
Open any other translation — the King James, the ESV, the NASB, the NIV — and there is no one there to be persuaded: there is “confirmation”. The strengthening of the faith. Paul guaranteed the gospel in person, with chains on his wrists.
But let us set philology aside too, and go to the heart of it. Let us stop for a moment and imagine what that doctrine really means. It means a God — the Almighty, the One who set the galaxies in order and holds the universe together — turning to his own and saying: “Do everything you can, lads, to get the world to accept My work. Get the permits. Obtain the recognitions. Bring Me the stamps.”
Let us really stop on this, because it is a dispiriting picture. Would the Holy Spirit who created the universe need the clearance of a court clerk? Would the Creator of all things wait for a registry office to give him the go-ahead to spread his own truth? It is belittling, before it is even false. It reduces the Almighty to an applicant at the counter, ticket number in hand, waiting for the world — Satan’s world, in their own doctrine — to grant him authorization to operate.
Doesn’t it turn your stomach just to imagine that scene?
God does not ask permission. God has never asked permission, as is only logical. Whoever thinks he must obtain it for him has already answered, without realizing it, the question of who really holds the work in his hands.
At this point their last defence kicks in, and it seems reasonable: “But we make no compromises. As long as we are not asked to betray a political or religious principle, using the world’s laws is lawful.” Separation remains intact — they say — because no principle is surrendered.
And this is where Scripture offers the image that cuts more cleanly than any argument. Jehoshaphat was a faithful king: he never worshipped idols, made no religious compromise, his doctrinal record was spotless. And yet his military alliance with Ahab cost him dearly, and a prophet called him to account for it (2 Chronicles 18; 19:2) — because he had chosen to lean on a human ally, on a shield of the world, instead of trusting in God. No idol. No betrayal of doctrine. Just the wrong shield. And that was enough.
Here is what dismantles the alibi of “as long as we don’t do politics, everything is lawful”: betrayal is not necessarily the idol. It is preferring the world’s shield to God’s shield, even while remaining “pure” in name. You can bow to no statue and have already shifted your trust, the moment you run to look elsewhere for the protection you said you awaited from Him alone.
None of this concerns the personal lawsuits that individuals may decide to bring: God has allowed man to govern himself precisely in the absence of His Kingdom.
It concerns the supposed management of the Kingdom’s affairs by those who declare themselves its representatives, whether as individuals or as an organization.
In an article on this blog, in 2018, a question was asked, and the question was this.
Who do we turn to when things get serious?
Let us keep it in suspense a moment longer. The answer had been there for over a century and a half (and I did not see it, exactly as the others did not), but after that date more answers came, and one in particular. Written by a court. In euros. Now choose whether to look at it or not.
The figure down to the cent
On 11 June 2026 the European Court of Human Rights decided the case Christian Congregation of Jehovah’s Witnesses v. Italy. Against Italy — or, if we prefer their vocabulary, against a portion of Satan’s world.
Let us put things in order, and do so honestly, because on one point they were right, and the Court unanimously recognized it: the Italian State manages the agreements for the otto per mille without clear criteria, without time limits, without any possibility of appeal. Thirteen denominations signed their agreements between 1984 and 2021; they did not, and for no objective reason.
Discrimination established: no objection on that. It applies to them as to any other minority, and it is right that it was recognized.
The problem is everything else. And it is the rest that concerns this article.
First: nobody was preventing the work. This is not Russia. No ban, no confiscations, no arrests, no forbidden meetings. Legal personality since 1986, tax exemptions, marriages with civil effect, spiritual assistance in hospitals and prisons, preaching and publications untouched. No obstacle to preaching was removed: what was requested was access to a tap of public money. Quite a different thing from going to court to defend oneself against persecution.
Second — and here the doctrine already starts making strange noises — they were already taking money from the system. According to the figures supplied by the Government itself to the Court, the cinque per mille contribution (another share of income tax that taxpayers can assign) for the year 2016 alone amounted to €1,226,254.95. One million two hundred thousand euros, collected from that very same world of Satan.
So the separation is not a matter of principle: State money, in itself, is perfectly fine. The point was not whether to take public money, but how much: they wanted the richer channel too. Separation from the world ends exactly where the otto per mille begins.
Third, and here we come to the figure. How much did they ask the State for? Two hundred million, three hundred and fifty-eight thousand, five hundred and eighteen euros and sixty-seven cents. €200,358,518.67. Down to the cent. Calculated not by the holy spirit but — as the court record states — by an accountant.
And it was not even compensation for a wrong. It was a calculation of how much tax revenue they would have pocketed if, in all those years, they had been inside the otto per mille system. Translated: “give me the arrears”. Assuming, moreover, that every single one of their adherents would have assigned them their share every single year. The Court rejected all of it: the claims rest on various conjectures, it wrote, and it cannot speculate on the outcome; the causal link has not been proven.
And when the main claim wobbled, the fallback appeared: all right, then give us at least seventy-five per cent. One hundred and fifty million. A downward haggle, on the record of a court, by those who claim not to trust in human governments and, still more, not to be part of the world.
Final result: ten thousand euros for non-pecuniary damage, eight thousand for costs. Eighteen thousand euros. Out of two hundred million: zero point zero zero nine per cent.
The point, however, is not whether they won or lost that case: that would make no difference to what we want to say.
The point we want to make is found just after that decimal point.
They could have won the principle and asked for a symbolic euro, as proof that they go forward “not by might, nor by power” — nor by money — “but by my spirit” (Zechariah 4:6). Instead they asked for two hundred million, three hundred and fifty-eight thousand, five hundred and eighteen euros and sixty-seven cents.
The cents are the confession.
So far, then, we have looked at what an organization says it is — God’s channel for ever, or since 1919, depending on who is listening. And at what it does when things get serious: it does not go as a sheep among wolves, it presents the wolves with the bill, down to the cent.
Everything else remains. No longer what they do, but which world the tools they use belong to — and why those tools, in the Bible, do not turn out to be lawful.
Which world do you come from?
There is an objection that, at this point, an attentive reader might raise.
“Fine about the excesses, fine about the two hundred million. But politics is one thing — voting, parties, flags — and we keep away from it; the courts are another — legal protection, the defence of one’s rights. They are two different things. One can reject the first and use the second without contradiction.”
It is a serious objection, and it deserves a serious answer, because it rests on a distinction we all take for granted: on one side political power, on the other judicial power.
Two separate spheres. Politics is rejected, but the courtroom is another matter.
Except that this distinction — let us stop here, because it is the heart of everything — is not biblical.
It is neither ancient nor revealed. It is a recent invention, and we even know who signed it.
The separation of powers — legislative, executive, judicial, each distinct and independent of the others — was born in 1748, in a book by a French philosopher: Montesquieu’s The Spirit of the Laws. Three centuries ago, not thirty. Before then it simply did not exist: it was a thought nobody had thought to formulate.
And what was power like before that distinction? A single block.
Whoever was in command made the law, judged whoever broke it and carried out the sentence, all in the same person.
We can see it in the Bible with the naked eye.
Nebuchadnezzar issues the decree (bow down to the statue), judges the offence (you did not bow down) and imposes the penalty (the furnace), all within a few verses, all by himself (Daniel 3).
Darius signs the decree, and when he would like to save Daniel he discovers he cannot revoke his own law: he is a prisoner of the power he himself embodies (Daniel 6).
In Scripture, power is one. The tripartition we take for granted is not there, because it was born twenty-six centuries later.
And here the question becomes simple, and sharp. If the separation between political and judicial power is a product of the world — indeed, one of its noblest products, designed precisely to rein in the tyrant — with what scalpel do we cut out the judicial branch and declare it clean, leaving only the political one dirty? It is the same tree. The same plant.
Rejecting politics and running to the courts is not leaving the world: it is simply choosing which room of its palace to settle into.
There is more, and it is the point that goes deepest.
A lawsuit, any lawsuit, is one man setting his strength against another man’s, before a third man who decides.
God, in this match, where is he? Nowhere. And not because of some abstract flaw in litigation: because of who sits in judgement.
The world’s forum is presided over by those very “unjust” we met earlier (1 Corinthians 6:1) — men who do not know God, and who therefore cannot deliver his judgement.
Here Paul says something his readers took almost for granted, and which today sounds enormous.
The Christian is not a subject begging for justice from the world’s court: he is destined to judge that world.
“Do ye not know that the saints shall judge the world?” (1 Corinthians 6:2). And further on: “Know ye not that we shall judge angels?” (1 Corinthians 6:3).
That is why, for a true Christian, when there is one, running to the unjust to have them prove him right is a reversal of stature before it is even a doctrinal error: it is the appointed judge queueing up before the defendant, hat in hand, to ask him for a ruling in his favour.
And now let us hold the mirror steady, because there is one last thing, and it comes from a text they know by heart.
For over a century and a half they have identified the “wild beast” of Revelation 13 with worldwide political power.
Very well. But let us reread the text they quote. The beast is given authority “over every tribe and people and language and nation” (Revelation 13:7): not a ministry, but full, total sovereignty — and full sovereignty includes judging.
And the second beast, the one rising out of the earth, what does it do?
It imposes, compels, punishes whoever does not conform (Revelation 13:15-17): it is a coercive apparatus, legislative, judicial and executive function in their purest state.
The text they have been quoting for a hundred and fifty years does not separate the powers at all. It describes them fused in the beast, exactly as in Daniel.
It is they who split the beast in two, keeping the half that suits them: “political” what is rejected, “judicial” what is used.
So much so that they have always forbidden any of their members to take part in politics (voting included), yet have never raised a single objection to the choice of becoming a lawyer or a judge.
As if the laws the judge is supposed to enforce did not come precisely from the politicians who make them.
The beast, in fact, never contemplated that division. If power is the beast, it is the beast all of it.
And there is a historical detail that strips this split even of the alibi of good faith.
Because the moment the judicial half is embraced is no ordinary moment: it is the very moment the other half, the political one, is pointed out as the enemy beast.
In the years when this identification became fixed — the beast as worldwide political power, taught from the 1920s onwards — the great courtroom campaigns also began. Five cases before the United States Supreme Court between 1938 and 1943, four of them won (Lovell, Cantwell, Murdock, Barnette). And not recounted with embarrassment, not as a necessary evil: claimed with pride.
One of their books devotes an entire chapter to it, and the title itself is a manifesto: “Watch Tower Society Defends the Good News in the Courts”. There they recount, with satisfaction, the effort to establish “a bulwark of favorable decisions”, and pay tribute to “the front-line fighters”.
And here we need a distinction many would take for granted, but which is precisely what brings the alibi down. One might say: but those were defences, not attacks — people arrested for preaching, protecting themselves.
True only in appearance. Because those cases were not “let me testify in the trial you dragged me into” — that is what Paul did, and nobody disputes it.
They were “grant me legal recognition of the right to preach”: petitions to obtain from the court permission to distribute the publications, to do the work. Something else, and the opposite.
Because Paul, before the judges, bore witness; but he never asked the empire for a licence to proclaim. And the first Christians, when the world forbade them to preach, did not file lawsuits: they preached underground, in the catacombs, in secret, without waiting for any office to authorize God’s work.
Nor can one point to the different form of government — “they didn’t file lawsuits because that form of government made no provision for them” — because the point is a different one.
The truth does not ask permission to exist and to be proclaimed. Whoever really possesses it proclaims it anyway, in chains or free, with the stamp or without it.
That is why those five cases do not resemble Paul being dragged at all. They resemble, rather, the man who joins the queue at the counter, ticket number in hand, waiting for the world to grant him authorization to operate on God’s behalf. Only here it is no longer an image: it is history, with dates and rulings.
And so the final image draws itself.
The same beast that struck them with one paw — the political one — handed them a safe-conduct with the other — the judicial one. And they decided, without the text allowing it, that the first paw was the beast and the second was not. They went to ask permission to preach from the very claws they had just declared hostile, convinced they were the claws of a different animal.
But the beast is one. Two paws, one animal. And whoever takes shelter under one of them while pointing to the other as the enemy has not left the lair: he has settled into it, choosing the most sheltered corner.
At this point an answer is ready, and it is the most honest one that can be given: “But we would preach anyway, regardless. We don’t need legal recognition as permission: it simply makes easier a work we would do in any case.”
It is a reasonable answer. Nobody is obliged to choose the harder road for the sake of principle. Let us take it at face value, then, and see where it leads.
It leads straight into two walls, both built by them.
The first is consistency. Because “it only makes things easier” is the exact opposite of what they teach. It is they who translated Paul’s verse as “legally establishing the good news”; it is they who made it a duty, an apostolic mandate, something the Christian is required to do. And now, cornered, they downgrade it to a convenience?
One or the other. Either it is a command — and then it is not a convenience, it is an obligation they stitched onto themselves by forcing a scripture; or it is a convenience — and then let them stop passing it off as the apostle’s teaching. You cannot brandish the verse as a duty when recruiting and reduce it to a shortcut when it has to be justified.
The second wall is simpler, and it is measured in money.
Let us even suppose it is only a convenience: the fact remains that it costs. An army of lawyers on the payroll, fees beyond counting. But if it really were only a matter of making easier a work that would be done anyway, and that is acknowledged to be guided by God, why spend a fortune? The best defender is already available, and he does not send an invoice.
Jesus promised him, in the very same discourse in which he announces the courts: “When they deliver you over, do not be anxious how you are to speak or what you are to say […] For it is not you who speak, but the Spirit of your Father speaking through you” (Matthew 10:19-20).
Let us reread it, because it is the same passage as before, just two verses further on.
You will be dragged before the courts (vv. 17-18), says Jesus; and once there — vv. 19-20 — don’t prepare your defence: I’ll see to it. That is the complete picture. The Christian is hauled into the forum by force, and there he hires no one: he opens his mouth and lets the Spirit speak.
Imagine it for a moment.
The Holy Spirit as defence counsel. Free of charge, the best there is, has never lost a case and never issues an invoice.
Whoever claims to have him and then hires a defence team costing nine figures is saying one of two things, in silence. And neither is pleasant to hear.
Either he does not trust the defender he has. Or he already knows that defender will not turn up — because the case is not one he pleads.

Does judicial power perhaps come from ANOTHER world?
Human rule weighed in the balances… rigged ones
One last question remains, and it concerns not what is used, but the yardstick one has.
Because whoever rejects the world’s governments has some idea of how the world ought to be governed. And has put it in writing.
In 1990 one of their magazines published a ten-part series entitled “Human Rule Weighed in the Balances”. A systematic review of the forms of government: anarchy, monarchy, aristocracy, democracy, autocracy, fascism, communism, or mixed forms. Promises and reality, one by one, with Plato, Aristotle, Locke and Lincoln called to testify. Comparative political philosophy, done properly, in ten instalments.
And let us concede the right thing straight away, because it is right: it is entirely consistent that whoever awaits God’s Kingdom should judge every human government inadequate. We would say so too.
An imperfect man does not make a perfect government, and on that there is nothing whatever to object.
The point is not that they fail them all. It is how they fail them. Because the hand does not always weigh the same for everyone.
The instalment on monarchy is entitled “Kings, Like Stars, Rise and Fall”.
Kings compared to stars: an almost elegiac title. It opens with a concession — monarchies “have always been considered helpful in holding nations together” — and the criticisms arrive in sober adjectives: absolute monarchies are “unsatisfactory” and “unstable”; parliamentary or limited ones “also fall short”. No hostile witness summoned. It closes, rightly, by looking to the perfect King.
The instalment on democracy has a different climate. There a firing squad parades: Elbridge Gerry calls it “the worst of all political evils”; Henry Miller quips: “The blind lead the blind. It’s the democratic way”; a leading democratic government is “a bloated, inefficient, helpless giant”; and vox populi vox Dei, it is pointed out, “is untrue”. Plus Plato, Socrates, Aristotle and a dozen others. Fifteen witnesses for the prosecution.
Three adjectives on one side, fifteen hostile quotations on the other. But the difference in tone is still the least of it.
Because on one of the two forms a genealogy is imposed that changes the very category of the judgement. Democracy, they write, is “an obvious continuation of the trend started in Eden, when humans decided to do things their way, not God’s way.”
Let us stop on this line. It is no longer a form of government imperfect like all human things: it is the continuation of original sin. And if in their own framework the proposal of self-determination, in Eden, comes from the serpent — decide for yourselves what is good and what is evil (Genesis 3:5) — then that form is not merely defective: it is demonic and rebellious from birth.
No such genealogy for monarchy, as if kings were not children of Adam and Eve. Kings rise and fall like stars: natural phenomena, passing, imperfect, even romantic. Democracy descends from the rebellion Satan instigated in Eden. Two weights, two categories — in a series entitled, of all things, “Weighed in the Balances”.
And now let us put the two side by side, as we have done from the start with everything else.
The form traced back to the rebellion in Eden is the one whose courts saved them in 1943, and to which they turned again in Strasbourg in 2026. The form treated with elegiac respect is the one in which — in the same magazine’s words — “the king’s word is law”: applied to them, it would have sent them into the furnace at the first decree. No hearings, no appeal, no Supreme Court reversing its own ruling three years later. Nebuchadnezzar does not schedule another hearing.
Not to mention Plato, quoted as wise and authoritative when he criticizes democracy, and as an absolute plague when he contaminates Christianity with philosophy.
It is the same mechanism as Montesquieu, under another name. The world’s tools are dirty when they contaminate doctrine, clean when they serve to judge governments. Political power dirty, judicial power clean. The Greek philosopher is poison in the chapter on the apostasy, an expert witness in the chapter on politics. Every time, the line falls where it is needed.
We too await a monarchy, let it be clear. A King whose word is law.
But the dividing line, in Scripture, has never been the form of power: it is who holds it and by what right. God reigns because he created all things (Revelation 4:11). The political beasts are the result of Satan’s interference with those who claimed that right for themselves: man.
That is why we do not change yardstick among the world’s forms of government, while recognizing that some forms are better for individual freedoms (and they are certainly not monarchies).
The Bible calls those who preside over them unjust, whatever the form (1 Corinthians 6:1), and identifies Satan as the real ruler of the world (John 14:30).
Ten articles weighing human rule in the balances would have been irreproachable, if on those scales everything had carried the same weight — at least from God’s point of view.
It did not carry the same weight, and this shows how they understand authority themselves, the authority with which they believe they are invested.
And of the separation of powers — a human device of 1748, not a page of Moses — nothing was ever weighed. No genealogy, no verdict.
The legislative branch is the beast; the judicial branch, evidently, comes from another world, and it is the counter where the petition is filed.
The boundary between the political and the judicial, in the Text, does not exist.
It is an artificial border drawn by them alone, and it always runs exactly across the threshold of the courtroom.
And finally, the concept of “organization” as they understand it does not appear in the Bible either — even though, as we said at the beginning, God’s people were organized indeed.
But they were a people organized by functions, each with his own, not a legal entity asking the world for permits, discounts on meeting halls, or changes to the laws of men through armies of lawyers on the payroll.
And above all they were a people who knew one thing only, but knew it well: that bending God’s Word to one’s own advantage comes at a price.
That the God of Israel, the true God, the One who had chosen them out of the world and set them apart, would sooner or later bring everyone before a far higher court.
They knew, with absolute certainty, that a hefty bill would arrive.
But of an entirely different kind from the ones we have talked about here.
Sources
The “always”. You Can Live Forever in Paradise on Earth (1982), chap. 23 “God’s Visible Organization” (pp. 191-202), par. 4 — “The Bible shows that Jehovah has always guided his servants in an organized way” (1980s edition, no longer in use). The study in private homes with “a Bible study aid, such as this book you are reading”: par. 28. The invitation to “serve notice” of withdrawal from one’s religion: par. 32.
The dating to 1919. The Watchtower (Study Edition), 15 July 2013, “Who Really Is the Faithful and Discreet Slave?”, par. 12.
The history book. Jehovah’s Witnesses—Proclaimers of God’s Kingdom (1993), chap. 4, “The Great Apostasy Develops”, pp. 33-41 (the Reformation “did not, however, mark a return to true worship and doctrine”); it is preceded by chap. 3, “Christian Witnesses of Jehovah in the First Century”, and followed by chap. 5, “Proclaiming the Lord’s Return (1870-1914)”.
The judgment. European Court of Human Rights, Christian Congregation of Jehovah’s Witnesses v. Italy, application no. 49687/16, First Section, 11 June 2026. Amount claimed: § 101 (€200,358,518.67; in the alternative €150,268,889, i.e. 75%). Cinque per mille 2016, €1,226,254.95: § 50 (figure supplied by the Government). Rejection of the pecuniary claim: §§ 104-108. Non-pecuniary damage awarded, €10,000: § 109; costs, €8,000: § 112.
The separation of powers. Montesquieu, The Spirit of the Laws (De l’esprit des lois), 1748.
The saints will judge the world and angels. 1 Corinthians 6:2-3 (in the same passage as the “unjust” of 6:1).
The US Supreme Court cases (1938-1943). Lovell v. Griffin (1938), Cantwell v. Connecticut (1940), Minersville v. Gobitis (1940, lost), Murdock v. Pennsylvania (1943), West Virginia v. Barnette (1943) — source: jw.org, milestones of their history in the United States. The celebration of the victories: chapter “Watch Tower Society Defends the Good News in the Courts”, in Centennial of the Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Pennsylvania (1984), pp. 22-23 (“a bulwark of favorable decisions”; “the front-line fighters”).
The assigned roles. Ephesians 4:11-12 (King James Version); the New World Translation (2013) renders it the same way — “some as evangelizers, some as shepherds and teachers”.
The promised defender. Matthew 10:19-20 (ESV) — in the same discourse as the “courts” of Matthew 10:17-18.
The review of forms of government. Awake! 1990, ten-part series “Human Rule Weighed in the Balances”. Monarchy: Part 2, “Kings, Like Stars, Rise and Fall”, 22 August 1990, pp. 16-20 (“helpful in holding nations together”; “unsatisfactory”; “unstable”; “also fall short”; “In an absolute monarchy, the king’s word is law”). Democracy: Part 4, “‘We the People’”, 22 September 1990, pp. 11-14 (Gerry, “the worst of all political evils”; Miller, “The blind lead the blind”; the “bloated, inefficient, helpless giant”, quoted from Time; vox populi vox Dei; democracy as “an obvious continuation of the trend started in Eden”; the merits granted to Athens: “freedom of speech”, a system of checks against misuse of power “considered to be a good idea”). Summary of the forms: Part 9, “Human Rule Reaches Its Climax!”, 8 December 1990, pp. 20-24 (imperfect men cannot make perfect governments).
The Adventist agreement. Agreement of 29 December 1986, ratified by Law no. 516 of 22 November 1988 (Italian Union of Seventh-day Adventist Christian Churches). The Adventists are among the denominations with access to the otto per mille; the agreement with Jehovah’s Witnesses, signed but never ratified, is the subject of the case decided in Strasbourg in 2026.
Plato the plague-spreader. Proclaimers (1993), chap. 4, box “Plato and ‘Christianity’”, p. 36 — his teachings would “eventually find their way into apostate Christianity” (Trinity, immortality of the soul).
Philippians 1:7. The Greek has βεβαίωσις, “confirmation, strengthening” (so the KJV and the ESV, “confirmation”; the same word occurs only in Hebrews 6:16). A forensic nuance is attested in the papyri as a guarantee in a transaction (Deissmann; Moulton-Milligan). New World Translation: “defending and legally establishing the good news” (1984 and 2013 editions).
Unless otherwise noted, Scripture quotations are from the King James Version (KJV) and from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved. Quotations marked as such are from the New World Translation of the Holy Scriptures.
Comments
Post a Comment